Six months after Nick Holly returned to Willowbrook, Vermont, and reconnected with former high school boyfriend Jolly Whitaker, Jolly wants to take their romance further. He knows Nick isn't ready for marriage after experiencing a difficult divorce, and it's too soon anyway, but he wants something more from Nick than a few nights a week. When he returns from visiting his son, Jolly plans an extravagantly romantic dinner for two with the help of family and friends. He hopes Nick will agree to move in with him. Nick agrees, to Jolly's delight, but when Nick finds a ring box hidden in Jolly's house, will Nick get the wrong impression and change his mind?