Jilted! Just before Mercy Yoder was to wed a man she'd known her whole life, he left her and their life for the Englischer world. To mend her heart and her pride, she leaves her small Amish community for a stay with her uncle. There Mercy meets handsome furniture builder Isaac Miller who, unbeknownst to her, played a role in her disgrace. Drawn to blue-eyed Mercy and consumed with guilt, Isaac prays to God for guidance, even as he starts falling in love with the one woman from whom he should stay away. When the man Mercy was to marry reappears to tempt her to come with him to a different life, she learns Isaac's secret. Can Mercy forgive him and accept his love?