Stories included in volume 4 of Creepy Crystal Tales are: "Are You Sure" tells about a man whose wife is buried alive and how the town decides to prevent future premature burials. "Chaos" is the story about a rampaging grizzly bear that attacks white settlers who place a bounty on his head. "Down to the Bone" gives details of the rapid spread of the dreaded flesh eating disease. "The Dark Angels of Death" depicts a father and his two sons that run a blacksmith shop and how they profit from the death of their customers. "The Aspen Grove Witch" is the story of Isabella Blackwood, an Irish witch who escapes to Crystal in order to hide from an abusive husband.