Hunter and Monica were a duet both on and off stage at Tyler Creek high school until he left her broken-hearted to follow his Broadway dreams. Fifteen years later, Monica has made peace with her decision to stay behind in their small town. She's become a drama teacher and is building a business with her best friend, Darcie. However, when Hunter returns to star in a benefit production for the local community theatre and Monica's cast as his love interest, their hearts are once again singing love songs. Will they find dissonance or harmony?