Paige Daniels and Gavin Foster might've been in love for half of their high school years, but while one of them is planning their future, the other needs a break. And on prom night, things come to a devastating head. They find their way back to each other in college, but an unexpected and overblown disagreement leads to them parting ways again. Now as adults, they're each in relationships and trying to pretend the other doesn't exist. Everyone but them can see they're not over each other. Gavin is coasting in a relationship that appears to be going nowhere and Paige is trying to convince herself that she's satisfied with a man that doesn't quite do it for her…and who also happens to be Gavin's former friend. Will they be able to let go of the past and let the third time be the charm?