I've been a good girl my whole life. All that careful obedience has built into a single, desperate need: I want a baby. Now. Not after a proper courtship, but tonight. And I want Joe Callahan to be the father. He's steady, kind, and has the hands of a man who knows what he's doing. My plan is simple: get him alone during the Easter church setup and ask him. No—tell him. But my plan hits a snag. Michael, the youth pastor and my friend of well over a decade, is there too. And when I finally get Joe alone and make my scandalous offer, he gives me an unthinkable condition. It's both of them, or it's nothing. Now I have to convince the most innocent man I know, a youth pastor, to help his father fulfill my deepest, most forbidden wish. In a church pew, surrounded by Easter lilies, I'm going to get exactly what I came for. I just never imagined I'd need two men to give it to me.