Noah Hunter spends his days teaching teenagers about physical fitness and his nights pursuing the women of Sun Valley. As he gets older, however, the less appealing one-night stands are and the more he longs for something real, but the last time the opportunity for love came his way, he blew it. Lucky for him, fate has a second chance at the ready. Caitlin Walsh spent her high school days falling in love with the football quarterback, but after a misunderstanding over a love letter, she isn’t sure she can trust her own judgement. A new job forces her to come face-to-face with the man that caused her problem, but this time around, it seems Noah is determined to fix the issues from their past to create a bright future for both of them. Will these two be able to work through the issues of the past? Or will their love story not be worth the effort?